Can protein bars truly replace a meal? An exploration.

1. Are Protein Bars an Optimal Choice?

2. Protein stick and a meal

3. Summary of consuming protein sticks

1. Are Protein Bars an Optimal Choice?

Whether protein bars are an optimal choice depends on their ingredients and the frequency and circumstances in which we use them. Unfortunately, not all protein bars available on the market are good in terms of composition and macronutrient ratios. A protein bar should contain a lot of protein, which makes up about 25-45% of its energy content. However, we should be careful with products that are only called protein-rich, but actually contain very little protein. Good sources of protein are, for example, whey protein isolates, whey protein hydrolysates, whey protein concentrates, casein, egg protein, soy protein or pea protein. Protein bars also contain carbohydrates (20-40%) and fats (about 20% energy content). We should pay attention to the presence of saturated fatty acids, which can have a negative impact on the lipid profile. Protein bars can also contain large amounts of sugar, trans fats and preservatives. It is worth checking the labels, as protein bars can also contain valuable vitamins and minerals, such as vitamin C, E, from the B group, as well as calcium, potassium and iron. Protein bars can also contain other additives, such as inulin – a natural prebiotic that has a positive effect on the gut flora.

2. Protein stick and a meal

A suitably balanced meal provides all the necessary nutrients (proteins, fats, carbohydrates) and vitamins and minerals. Recommendations for a balanced diet are clearly and simply presented on a healthy food plate. This plate was prepared by the National Institute of Public Health – State Institute of Hygiene and shows the suggested proportions of each group of compatible foods in the diet. In addition, it contains information on what to eat more and less and what to replace so that the diet is rich in nutritional recommendations. Particular attention should be paid to vegetables, which should be included in every meal and should make up half of the plate. A balanced meal is always a better choice than a protein stick. Firstly, it is larger in volume, which means it will satisfy us faster. Secondly, we have full control over what is on the plate, and fresh produce is a treasure trove of vitamins and minerals. It is worth mentioning that we can also prepare healthy protein sticks ourselves, based on simple and easily available ingredients. They can contain oats (e.g. oatmeal), nuts, nut butter, cocoa, fresh or dried fruit, protein-rich nutritional supplements, flaxseed or seeds.

3. Summary of consuming protein sticks

Consuming protein sticks can provide an additional source of energy and alleviate feelings of hunger. Their undeniable advantage is the small portion in a practical packaging that can be easily taken to work or school. The sticks can provide a quick energy injection in emergency situations when we are on the move and we don't have time to prepare a full meal, but they should not serve as the main source of nutrition – they should not be treated as a substitute for a properly balanced meal. Protein sticks can, however, be a valuable solution for people leading a very active lifestyle, such as athletes. They can also serve as a sweet snack that will be a better choice than traditional sweets. They are also a better option for people with disorders of carbohydrate metabolism, insulin resistance, or diabetes due to the replacement of sugar with sweeteners. It is important to emphasize, however, that protein sticks are only a supplement and will certainly not replace a properly balanced diet and physical activity. It is worth paying attention to the content of the product when choosing it – the shorter, the better. With good content, however, a higher price is often associated.